Heyo,
There has been one discussion in the milestone which didn't produce a productive follow up, and no clear improvement could be thought of.
The "problem" is that new users of Openclonk don't know of the whereabouts of the location of the screenshot (records, log, player) folder, nor do they know that the quicklink "Benutzerpfad" will lead to it.
I'm absolutely fine with appdata, once you get to know it - the problem is that a lot of users did not know of it at the start, and as such the location was considered not newbiefriendly in the previous milestone discussions.
Now some suggested that instead of appdata, the files should be stored somewhere into "Eigene Dateien / My Documents" - but in my book that would be equally unclear.
Others suggested that you store everything in the clonk folder - bad idea either, I think a general folder makes a lot of sense with all those Clonk versions around (Snapshot, stable, if you are a developer also repository) - and would otherwise lead to a lot of copying around and confusion.
Now in the last discussion I brought up a button in the main menu leading to the data folder, but thats also bad since that would force Clonk to loose focus in fullscreen - that will probably annoy the users.
So as it stands we didn't come up with a solution. The only thing I could think of is postponing this discussion and feature a link or button in developer mode once we have established an editor like windmill (or another one, you never know).
Any ideas where to place hints to reach the folder easier?
There has been one discussion in the milestone which didn't produce a productive follow up, and no clear improvement could be thought of.
The "problem" is that new users of Openclonk don't know of the whereabouts of the location of the screenshot (records, log, player) folder, nor do they know that the quicklink "Benutzerpfad" will lead to it.
I'm absolutely fine with appdata, once you get to know it - the problem is that a lot of users did not know of it at the start, and as such the location was considered not newbiefriendly in the previous milestone discussions.
Now some suggested that instead of appdata, the files should be stored somewhere into "Eigene Dateien / My Documents" - but in my book that would be equally unclear.
Others suggested that you store everything in the clonk folder - bad idea either, I think a general folder makes a lot of sense with all those Clonk versions around (Snapshot, stable, if you are a developer also repository) - and would otherwise lead to a lot of copying around and confusion.
Now in the last discussion I brought up a button in the main menu leading to the data folder, but thats also bad since that would force Clonk to loose focus in fullscreen - that will probably annoy the users.
So as it stands we didn't come up with a solution. The only thing I could think of is postponing this discussion and feature a link or button in developer mode once we have established an editor like windmill (or another one, you never know).
Any ideas where to place hints to reach the folder easier?

No, we should really just stop dumping EVERYTHING into a hidden folder and use the correct ones for stuff we create (in this case FOLDERID_Screenshots on Win8+, FOLDERID_Pictures on other Windows, no idea where to store stuff on Linux or Darwin)

>no idea where to store stuff on Linux or Darwin
At least in the /home/user directory I would say. How different are the folders between distros/versions(/languages)?

Why not just include the complete path or at least \AppData\Roaming\OpenClonk\Screenshots ?
Why is the user path folder in AppData and not in the Documents folder? The AppData folder is usually hidden, so new users might have problems to find it.


Putting all garbage in Documents is not a very nice thing to do.


Powered by mwForum 2.29.7 © 1999-2015 Markus Wichitill